Add several drops of orange food coloring to your vanilla frosting and mix well until you have your desired color.

Turn your cookies with the solid fudge side placing up, then place a heaping spoonful of orange frosting in the center of your cookie.

Stick your peanut butter cup on top of the frosting, with the smaller side facing up. Push down gently so the orange frosting forms a ring around the peanut butter cup.

Put an M&M candy into the orange frosting so it rests against the peanut butter cup.

And you're done! You can add a pilgrim hat cookie to the top of a frosted cupcake, but these cookies do look great on their own!