Fun and Yummy Gelatin Eggs

Hello to all you Somewhat Simple readers! My name is Laura and I am the new kid’s crafts contributor. Before I get started telling you about the fun gelatin eggs I made for my son, I thought I would tell you a little about myself. I recently left my career as a scientist to stay home with my little boy who just turned two. I now do all my experimenting at home and enjoy creating all sorts of things.  I am a firm believer that you can figure out how to make anything using your brain and hands. I share this passion with my readers on my blog, The Experimental Home. Nice to meet you! Okay let’s get started.

fun and yummy gelatin eggsWhen did stores start stocking Easter stuff? The day after Valentine’s Day? It seems like chocolate hearts turned into chocolate eggs overnight, right?. Since that day, my two-year-old son has been saying,  “Big eggs!” or “Yellow eggs!” or “Buy eggs, Mama!” every time we walk past a display of plastic eggs.  Even though it was still waaaay before Easter, I caved one day. I mean they were only $.99 a package, and he was soooo excited. I bought two packages, one for him to play with and a second to use as gelatin molds for even more egg-tastic fun!

To turn regular plastic eggs into gelatin molds, you need to poke a hole in the eggs to pour liquid gelatin through. I elected to put the hole in the bottom of the egg and mold the gelatin eggs upside down.

turn plastic eggs into gelatin egg moldsI used an little, old screwdriver and a lighter to make the holes. Note… some parts of this project are appropriate for older kids to help with, this part should be done carefully, by adults only. I placed my eggs upside down in a regular egg crate. I lit the lighter and stuck the screwdriver into the fire to heat it up. Once it was hot, I poked through the bottom of the egg turning it as I went to make a good-sized round hole, and then repeated for each egg.

In order to get stuff in the holes I poked, I made tiny funnels out of straws. I cut the straws to around 2 inch lengths and then made a small (1 cm) slit in the side of the straw. Folding back the corners on each side of the slit allows the straw to function as a funnel.

turn plastic eggs into gelatin moldsBefore I could use these eggs as molds, I had to deal with the small hole around the top of the egg (as you can see above, there is one on the bottom too, but I didn’t worry about that one). I assume the holes are to prevent a buildup of pressure when you close the eggs. For this project, they are a pain in the you-know-what. I elected to cover them with electrical tape, working hard to seal the hole. You could also use duct tape or any other water-proof barrier. Honestly, a few of my eggs leaked. I had leaks through the tape, and leaks through the center seam. Next time I make gelatin eggs,  I will be extra careful to seal the hole, close the eggs tightly, and may even tape around the circumference of the egg to reinforce the seal. I imagine that slightly better quality eggs than the ones I bought would work better.

tape over hole in gelatin egg moldNow that I had functional molds, it was time to make some gelatin. The gelatin I made is akin to super-firm panna cotta, and results in opaque eggs. You could certainly use j-e-l-l-o if you prefer, but I think it is easier to make multiple colors if you make your own.

For 1 dozen medium-sized eggs, bring 2 cups of water to a boil in a medium sized sauce pan.  Add 1 oz (1 box) of unflavored gelatin and stir until dissolved/melted. Remove pan from heat. Stir in 1/3 cup sugar, 1 tsp vanilla and 1 1/2 cup cold milk. Working with 1 cup of gelatin at a time, add 3-5 drops of food coloring, stir until combined, then pour carefully (my measuring cup with a spout worked perfectly) into the eggs through the straw funnel. Each cup of mixture will fill 3-4 eggs, depending on how neat you are. If your egg springs a leak, stop, clean up the mess, reseal the hole, and try again. Do not keep pouring or else you will have a big mess on your hands.

pouring gelatin into egg moldsClose your egg carton, and pop it in the fridge for at least 1-2 hours. They set up fairly quickly. Simply open the egg to unmold… or leave that part to your little one.

playing with gelatin eggsI try to do crafts and activities with my little guy often. Generally he enjoys himself for 10-20 minutes before losing interest. That was not the case with these eggs. He loved them. He played with them for an hour and a half, at least. Seriously. He unmolded them, then put them back in the plastic eggs. He squished, squeezed jiggled and bounced the gelatin eggs. He related the color of the plastic eggs to the color of the gelatin eggs inside and mixed and matched the colors. He took bites out of some eggs, and loved the sweet, creamy, vanilla  flavor. He had a ball (or an egg, to be precise).

playing with gelatin eggsNow, every time we see plastic eggs he says, “Make more eggs, Mama!” I will have to make more soon!

fun and yummy gelatin eggs

I hope you enjoy making gelatin eggs with your kiddos this year. Happy Easter!


The Creative Team of Somewhat Simple

The Creative Team of Somewhat Simple

We are a creative group of ladies who strive to make our families happier and our homes prettier. Follow along as we bring you creative content that is sure to inspire!
The Creative Team of Somewhat Simple

Latest posts by The Creative Team of Somewhat Simple (see all)



  1. says

    What a great idea! My kids are not egg eaters…so at Easter time we dye eggs, hunt eggs, and then throw eggs away! Kinda wasteful. This is a great alternative for those of us who don’t love a hard-boiled eggs.

    • Laura says

      I bet your kids will love to eat these gelatin eggs, Haley! And I understand, I only like hard boiled eggs in egg salad.

  2. Jennifer says

    Love this idea but when I tried it, the eggs fell apart as I took the plastic egg part off. Did I do something wrong with the jelly that it just didn’t get hard enough? Or do I need to spray the inside of the plastic eggs with oil or something (though that would affect the taste of the eggs). I will experiment a bit and try it again today!

    • Laura says

      Oh no! I am so sorry. A whole box of gelatin should be more than enough to firmly set 3 1/2 cups of liquid. Try running the eggs under hot water before you unmold them.

      • Jennifer says

        Thanks! :) I’ve tried again … they are currently in the fridge trying to set. I will run under hot water too before I unmold them later today. :)

  3. Jessica says

    I have molds that I bought. The recipe suggests spraying or swiping the inside with oil. I prefer to swipe it as the spray leaves little pits in the eggs where the droplets of oil are. If you choose to use Jello use only 1/2 the normal amount of water.